Skip to Content

How to Get Insurance to Pay for Roof Replacement

How to Get Insurance to Pay for Roof Replacement

Roof replacement after storm damage can be a financial and logistical nightmare for homeowners. Roof damage alone is responsible for about 41% of homeowner’s insurance claims.

Use this to your advantage by learning how to get insurance to pay for roof replacement. It’s really not hard, and the vendor will do all the heavy lifting.

Let’s walk through the roof replacement process step-by-step and cover the different reasons your homeowner’s insurance could choose to cover the cost or deny your claim.

If you’re prepared and have the right information and proof to show your insurance company, your odds of getting the replacement or repairs covered will drastically increase.

Get a Quote
Find Roofing Companies

We partnered with Networx to help you find local roofing companies. Click to below to get a FREE quote.

Find Roofers
We may earn a commission when you click this link, at no extra cost to you.

How to Get Insurance to Pay for Roof Replacement

A close up view of shingles a roof damage


The need for roof repairs or replacement starts with what insurance companies call an act of nature. Some companies call this an “act of God”.

This can be a damaging storm with high winds and heavy rain, a tornado, a hurricane, or hail damage. Large amounts of snow and ice can also strain your roof to the breaking point.

Verisk Analytics found that hail damage has been the fastest-growing cause of roof damage since 2007. Once an act of nature occurs and causes roof damage, it’s time to take action and start documenting everything.

Start by finding a great roofing contractor. They will be an important ally for you during this process.

Find the Right Roofing Contractor

An experienced contractor who has successfully worked with insurance companies and adjusters is the best support you can have in this situation. Ask around to see if friends or family have recommendations.

When you find a good contractor, tell them your situation and ask for their advice. You’ll want to review your policy with your contractor and make sure it covers the kind of damage you’re dealing with.

Experienced roofing companies will have dealt with hundreds, if not thousands, of customers and their insurance policies over the years.

They won’t mind reviewing yours and giving you a free quote in order to get your business. With the right contractor or company on your team, you’re ready to get started on step number two.

Cover the Damaged Roof Right Away

Storm damaged roof on house with a protective blue plastic tarp spread over hole in the shingles and rooftop

Mike Focus/Shutterstock

Most likely, your homeowners policy will require you to cover the damaged roof immediately to protect the roof from further storm or water damage. Make sure this is done right away.

This way, you have the best chance of having your claim accepted. Roofs that are damaged by storms and then left vulnerable to the elements are usually denied repair and replacement claims.

Your contractor will understand the importance of this and ensure the roof is covered properly and safe from further damage.

Once the roof is properly tarped and covered, it should be secure until you are able to get the actual repairs done.

File an Insurance Claim Within 30 Days

If your roof was damaged in a storm, chances are that many other roofs in your area were damaged too.

To make sure you are at the front of the line when it comes to claim approval, submit your claim as soon as possible after covering the damaged roof—and definitely within 30 days.

Insurance companies view your claim and the adjusters who handle your claim as an expense. Claims do not make the insurance company money. They lose money.

Most states give you anywhere from 30 to 60 days after the damage occurs to file your claim.

Filing later gives your insurance company a valid reason to deny your claim. Unfortunately, many claims end up being denied for easily avoided reasons like this.

Do whatever is in your power to increase your chances of getting your claim approved and your roof replacement cost covered.

Prepare for the Insurance Adjuster

Young man inspecting the roof of an old house standing on a ladder


It isn’t that you shouldn’t trust your insurance company. After all, you wouldn’t be a customer if you believed they were dishonest.

But knowing that their main objective is making money, not paying claims, it’s important to act in your own best interest.

Your claims adjuster will come to your home and inspect your roof, as well as review any other documentation you have ready.

This is why it’s important to have all your documentation and an independent roof inspection before your insurance adjuster comes out.

What will the insurance adjuster look for during their inspection? There are several things the adjuster will assess.

Your roofing contractor will use the same criteria to inspect your roof, and having two professional opinions will only make your case stronger.

Roof Inspection Criteria

Before you file a claim, you should understand a few things that would disqualify you from having insurance pay for your roof replacement. A few of them include:

  • Was your roof correctly installed to begin with?
  • Were the roofing materials defective?
  • Is your attic vented properly?
  • Is the damage only cosmetic?
  • How much of the roof needs to be repaired or replaced?
  • Has it been adequately covered and secured since the damage occurred?

Along with this inspection, your adjuster is going to want some additional documentation.

Having a few photos taken before and after the damage is fine, but it’s better to “over-prepare” and have at least five forms of documentation ready. These include:

  • A copy (digital or physical) of your homeowner’s insurance policy
  • Before and after photos of your home and the roof
  • Close-up photos of the damaged areas
  • Written assessment of the roof damage by your contractor
  • Receipts for any repair work up to this point
  • Last home inspection date, reports, and findings
  • Documentation of premiums paid on-time
  • Accept or refuse the settlement

If you’ve followed the above instructions to file your roof claim, your insurance agent will probably accept your claim and make you an offer of settlement. This is a sum of cash to help pay for the cost of the repairs or replacement.

This settlement is meant to cover the cost of replacing your roof with materials that are the same quality as your old roof.

Your roofing contractor will be able to walk you through this process, as they will know exactly how much those materials will cost.

They can help you determine whether or not your insurance company’s offer is good enough. If it isn’t, your contractor can put pressure on your insurance company to increase the settlement amount.

Get a Quote
Find Roofing Companies

We partnered with Networx to help you find local roofing companies. Click to below to get a FREE quote.

Find Roofers
We may earn a commission when you click this link, at no extra cost to you.

So, How Do You Get Insurance to Pay for Roof Replacement?

If you’re unable to come to an agreement with your insurance company, you’ll be forced to accept the settlement amount they’ve given you. Maybe you are unhappy with that amount.

Or perhaps it doesn’t cover the full cost of the materials and labor to get your roof fixed; consider moving to a different insurance company. It’s overwhelming when a storm or act of nature damages your roof.

You can make the process less painful by aligning yourself with an experienced roofing company and documenting everything.

Once you’ve wrapped up your claim and received your settlement, continue to be a responsible homeowner by doing a few things.

These include having regular roof and home inspections, documenting with photos, and reading the fine print in your insurance policy.

Should you ever need to file another claim, you’ll be better prepared and more confident.